Desmoplastic malignant melanoma (DMM) and spindle cell malignant melan
oma (SCMM) form a continuum without a discrete separation. One feature
characteristic of DMM is a negative reaction for HMB45, a marker for
premelanosomes. Fifty-six cases of SCMM were stained with HMB45. The c
linical features, histologic features, and survival data for HMB45(+)
and HMB45(-) SCMM were compared. Thirty cases were HMB45(-), and 26 we
re HMB45(+). In the HMB45(-) cases, there was a 1.4:1 ratio of males t
o females, and in the HMB45(+) cases the ratio was 1:1.5. Only 12.9% o
f the HMB45(-) cases occurred on the trunk compared with 40% of the HM
B45(+) cases. The average ages for the HMB45(-) and the HMB45(+) cases
were 65.6 and 61 years, respectively. Follow-up was obtained on 22 ca
ses: 11 HMB45(-) and 11 HMB45(+). Of the 11 HMB45(-) cases, four had a
5-year disease-free survival. Of the 11 HMB45(+) cases, only one had
a 5-year disease free survival. HMB45(-) SCMM appear to have a less ag
gressive biologic potential than HMB45(+) SCMM.