E. Liden et al., ODOR-ANNOYANCE ESTIMATES FROM ROAD-TRAFFIC COMBUSTION EXHAUSTS - CALIBRATION WITH MASTER SCALING USING PYRIDINE AS A REFERENCE, Environment international, 23(6), 1997, pp. 829-837
The present field study addressed the need for a procedure that provid
es a defined unit of measurement of perceived annoyance from environme
ntal odors, calibrating the estimates for individual scaling behavior
and context effects. In including 25 subjects, the purpose was to demo
nstrate the applicability of the master-scale procedure with magnitude
estimation to perform such a calibration of odor-annoyance estimates
for target stimuli such as road-traffic combustion exhausts (13 000 ve
hicles/d; averaging 47 mu g/m(3) over the day/night with peaks exceedi
ng 100 mu g/m(3) of nitrogen dioxide; NO2). For comparison, calibrated
estimates were also obtained for a backyard expected to be considerab
ly less polluted (comparable with 18 mu g/m(3) of NO2) and for blank s
timuli presented indoors. The data transformation for the calibration
procedure with which annoyance is expressed in either master-scale uni
ts or pyridine equivalents requires estimates of a reference stimulus
for which seven concentrations of pyridine were used. The results prov
ide an illustration of master scaling of odor annoyance, and imply tha
t use of a modulus (standard stimulus with a predefined annoyance magn
itude), in contrast to master scaling, is not sufficient for calibrati
on for individual scaling behavior and context effects. (C) 1997 Elsev
ier Science Ltd.