H. Mackinger et al., Differences in the ratings of valence and concreteness for verbal conceptsbetween depressive and nondepressive persons, Z EXP PSYCH, 46(2), 1999, pp. 107-114
This study tries to reveal differences in the valency and concreteness rati
ngs for nouns, verbs, and adverbs between depressive (N = 20) and nondepres
sive (N = 20) persons. For the valency ratings the results show significant
differences between the two groups and between the syntactical categories
as well as an interaction between the factors group and syntactical categor
ies. For concreteness ratings we found a significant main effect for the gr
oup factor, a significant interaction between group and syntactical categor
ies, and also a significant three way interaction between group, syntactica
l categories, and word valency. From these results it follows that, before
conducting experiments in clinical psychology, one must establish the parti
cipants' representation of words that are used as stimuli. Otherwise, resul
ts could easily be misinterpreted as specific experimental results.