As. Hilibrand et al., Radiculopathy and myelopathy at segments adjacent to the site of a previous anterior cervical arthrodesis, J BONE-AM V, 81A(4), 1999, pp. 519-528
Citations number
25
Categorie Soggetti
Ortopedics, Rehabilitation & Sport Medicine","da verificare
Background: We studied the incidence, prevalence, and radiographic progress
ion of symptomatic adjacent-segment disease, which we defined as the develo
pment of new radiculopathy or myelopathy referable to a motion segment adja
cent to the site of a previous anterior arthrodesis of the cervical spine,
Methods: A consecutive series of 374 patients who had a total of 409 anteri
or cervical arthrodeses for the treatment of cervical spondylosis,vith radi
culopathy or myelopathy, or both, were followed for a maximum of twenty-one
years after the operation. The annual incidence of symptomatic adjacent-se
gment disease was defined as the percentage of patients who had been diseas
e-free at the start of a given year of follow-up in whom new disease develo
ped during that year. The prevalence was defined as the percentage of all p
atients in whom symptomatic adjacent-segment disease developed within a giv
en period of follow-up, The natural history of the disease was predicted wi
th use of a Kaplan-Meier survivorship analysis. The hypothesis that new dis
ease at an adjacent level is more likely to develop following a multilevel
arthrodesis than it is following a single-level arthrodesis was tested,vith
logistic regression.
Results: Symptomatic adjacent-segment disease occurred at a relatively cons
tant incidence of 2.9 percent per year (range, 0.0 to 4.8 percent per year)
during the ten years after the operation, Survivorship analysis predicted
that 25.6 percent of the patients (95 percent confidence interval, 20 to 32
percent) who had an anterior cervical arthrodesis would have new disease a
t an adjacent level within ten years after the operation. There were highly
significant differences among the motion segments,vith regard to the likel
ihood of symptomatic adjacent-segment disease (p < 0.0001); the greatest ri
sk was at the interspaces between the fifth and sixth and between the sixth
and seventh cervical vertebrae, Contrary to our hypothesis, we found that
the risk of new disease at an adjacent level was significantly lower follow
ing a multilevel arthrodesis than it was following a single-level arthrodes
is (p < 0.001), More than two-thirds of all patients in whom the new diseas
e developed had failure of nonoperative management and needed additional op
erative procedures.
Conclusions Symptomatic adjacent-segment disease may affect more than one-f
ourth of all patients within ten years after an anterior cervical arthrodes
is. A single-level arthrodesis involving the fifth or sixth cervical verteb
ra and preexisting radiographic evidence of degeneration at adjacent levels
appear to be the greatest risk factors for new disease. Therefore, we beli
eve that all degenerated segments causing radiculopathy or myelopathy shoul
d be included in an anterior cervical arthrodesis, Although our findings su
ggest that symptomatic adjacent-segment disease is the result of progressiv
e spondylosis, patients should be informed of the substantial possibility t
hat new disease will develop at an adjacent level over the long term.