Jd. Wilkerson et D. Carrell, Money, politics, and medicine: The American medical PAC's strategy of giving in US house races, J HEALTH P, 24(2), 1999, pp. 335-355
We examine contributions by the American Medical Association's political ac
tion committee (AMPAC) to candidates for seats in the U.S. House of Represe
ntatives during two electoral cycles (1989-1990 and 1991-1992). In contrast
to earlier studies, we do not find any systematic evidence to support the
conventional wisdom that AMPAC contributes to influence legislators' positi
ons on roll call votes or that AMPAC's contribution decisions are influence
d by legislators' voting positions. We do find that AMPAC contributes to pr
omote access to decision makers and to help elect (or reelect) legislators
who would be expected to be more generally sympathetic to the economic and
practice concerns of AMA physicians. As points of comparison, we also exami
ne contributions from the top five tobacco PACs and the National Rifle Asso
ciation's (NRA) PAC and find that legislators' roll call voting positions a
re strongly related to contributions received from these organizations.