Jd. Fuentes et al., MODELED AND FIELD-MEASUREMENTS OF BIOGENIC HYDROCARBON EMISSIONS FROMA CANADIAN DECIDUOUS FOREST, Atmospheric environment, 29(21), 1995, pp. 3003-3017
The Biogenic Emission Inventory System (BEIS) used by the United State
s Environmental Protection Agency (Lamb et al., 1993, Atmospheric Envi
ronment 21, 1685-1705; Pierce and Waldruff, 1991, J. Air Waste Man. As
s. 41, 937-941) was tested for its ability to provide realistic microc
limate descriptions within a deciduous forest in Canada. The microclim
ate description within plant canopies is required because isoprene emi
ssion rate's from plants are strongly influenced by foliage temperatur
e and photosynthetically active radiation impinging on leaves while mo
noterpene emissions depend primarily on leaf temperature. Model microc
limate results combined with plant emission rates and local biomass di
stribution were used to derive isoprene and alpha-pinene emissions fro
m the deciduous forest canopy. In addition, modelled isoprene emission
estimates were compared to measured emission rates at the leaf level.
The current model formulation provides realistic microclimatic condit
ions for the forest crown where modelled and measured air and foliage
temperature are within 3 degrees C. However, the model provides inadeq
uate microclimate characterizations in the lower canopy where estimate
d and measured foliage temperatures differ by as much as 10 degrees C.
This poor agreement may be partly due to improper model characterizat
ion of relative humidity and ambient temperature within the canopy. Th
ese uncertainties in estimated foliage temperature can lead to underes
timates of hydrocarbon emission estimates of two-fold. Moreover, the m
odel overestimates hydrocarbon emissions during the early part of the
growing season and underestimates emissions during the middle and latt
er part of the growing season. These emission uncertainties arise beca
use of the assumed constant biomass distribution of the forest and con
stant hydrocarbon emission rates throughout the season. The BEIS model
, which is presently used in Canada to estimate inventories of hydroca
rbon emissions from vegetation, underestimates emission rates by at le
ast two-fold compared to emissions derived from field measurements. Th
e isoprene emission algorithm proposed by Guenther et al. (1993), appl
ied at the leaf level, provides relatively good agreement compared to
measurements. Field measurements indicate that isoprene emissions chan
ge with leaf ontogeny and differ amongst tree species. Emission rates
defined as function of foliage development stage and plant species nee
d to be introduced in the hydrocarbon emission algorithms. Extensive m
odel evaluation and more hydrocarbon emission measurements from differ
ent plant species are required to fully assess the appropriateness of
this emission calculation approach for Canadian forests.