Objectives. Urologists routinely use the systematic sextant needle biopsy t
echnique to detect prostate cancer. However, recent evidence suggests that
this technique has a significant sampling error. We developed a novel three
-dimensional (3D) computer-assisted prostate biopsy simulator based on whol
e-mounted step-sectioned radical prostatectomy specimens to compare the dia
gnostic accuracy of various prostate needle biopsy protocols.
Methods. We obtained digital images of 201 step-sectioned whole-mounted rad
ical prostatectomy specimens. 3D computer simulation software was developed
to accurately depict the anatomy of the prostate and all individual tumor
foci. Additional peripheral devices were incorporated into the system to pe
rform interactive prostate biopsies. We obtained 18 biopsies of each prosta
te model to determine the detection rates of various biopsy protocols.
Results. The 10- and 12-pattern biopsy protocols had a 99.0% detection rate
; the traditional sextant biopsy protocol rate was only 72.6%. The 5-region
biopsy protocol had a 90.5% detection rate and the 14-pattern, which inclu
des all the biopsies used in the patterns above, only added 1 additional po
sitive case (99.5%). Transitional zone and seminal vesicle biopsies did not
result in a significantly increased detection rate when added to the patte
rns above. Only one positive model was obtained when the transitional zone
biopsies were added, The lateral sextant pattern had a detection rate of 95
.5%, and the 4-pattern lateral biopsy protocol had a 93.5% detection rate.
Conclusions. Our results suggest that all the biopsy protocols that use lat
erally placed biopsies based on the 5-region anatomic model are superior to
the routinely used sextant prostate biopsy pattern. Lateral biopsies in th
e mid and apical zones of the gland are the most important. UROLOGY 53: 961
-967, 1999. Published by Elsevier Science Inc.