Mj. Grainge et al., Association between a family history of fractures and bone mineral densityin early postmenopausal women, BONE, 24(5), 1999, pp. 507-512
association between a family history of fractures and bone mineral density
(BMD), and to determine what definition of family fracture history best pre
dicts BMD. Five hundred and eighty postmenopausal women aged 45-59 at recru
itment completed a risk factor questionnaire. Women were asked to recall de
tails of fractures sustained by any female relative. BMD measurements taken
at five sites were used. The data were analysed using linear regression, a
djusting for age. Two hundred and ninety-seven (52.8%) women reported a fam
ily history of fractures, and they had a significantly lower BMD at two of
the sites measured (p < 0.05), The associations with BMD were most signific
ant when only counting fractures that occurred in the subject's mother or a
sister as a result of low trauma, with no restrictions made on age at the
time of fracture and site of fracture (p < 0.01 at three sites; 0.01 < p <
0.05 at two sites). Women with a family history according to this definitio
n had a 4.6% reduction in BMD at the femoral neck. When T scores were used
to categorize women as either osteopenic/osteoporotic (T < -1) or normal at
the femoral neck, the sensitivity of using this definition was 39% and the
specificity was 74%, The small group of women that reported a low-trauma h
ip fracture in a mother or sister (n = 23) had a mean femoral neck BMD whic
h was 8.9% lower than that of the remainder of the sample, although this di
fference was less statistically significant than when low trauma fractures
at any site were counted, Of these 23 women, 70% were osteopenic or osteopo
rotic, compared with 57% of those reporting a low-trauma fracture at any si
te and 47% of the sample as a whole. The sensitivity of this definition, ho
wever, was low (6%), From these analyses it can be concluded that the defin
ition of family fracture history that best predicts BMD in postmenopausal w
omen is a fracture at any age in a mother or sister resulting from low trau
ma, although the sensitivity and specificity of using a family history of f
ractures by itself to screen for low BMD were poor. (C) 1999 by Elsevier Sc
ience Inc. All rights reserved.