Jm. Von Der Werth et al., Compositae mix is a more sensitive test for Compositae dermatitis than thesesquiterpene lactone mix, CONTACT DER, 40(5), 1999, pp. 273-276
Over the past 2 decades, Compositae dermatitis has increasingly been recogn
ized as a cause of exposure-pattern dermatitis. The introduction of the ses
quiterpene lactone (SL) mix as a screening test has contributed to this imp
roved recognition. However, there is growing evidence that the SL mix fails
to detect a substantial number of genuine Compositae allergies. We therefo
re investigated whether another screening reagent (the Compositae mix) migh
t be more sensitive in detecting cases of Compositae allergy than the SL mi
x. Over a 1-year period, we tested 656 consecutive unselected patch test pa
tients to both SL mix and Compositae mix. 31 patients were found to have ge
nuine Compositae allergies. Of these, 28 had reacted to the Compositae mix
but only 13 had reacted to the SL mix. The Compositae mix failed to detect
only 2 genuine Compositae allergies, whereas the SL mix missed 17 such alle
rgies. On the other hand, the Compositae mix led to 9 irritant reactions, w
hile there was only 1 irritant reaction with the SL mix. We conclude that C
ompositae dermatitis is still being underdiagnosed with the current screeni
ng method, and that the Compositae mix is significantly more sensitive in d
etecting Compositae allergy than the SL mix.