Jj. Gregory et Jl. Finlay, alpha-fetoprotein and beta-human chorionic gonadotropin - Their clinical significance as tumour markers, DRUGS, 57(4), 1999, pp. 463-467
Tumour markers can aid in areas such as diagnosis, surveillance of recurren
ce, staging and prognosis. This article focuses on 2 tumour markers, alpha-
fetoprotein (AFP) and beta-human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG). These tumour
markers have been examined for their utility as prognostic indicators in 2
different manners. First, the marker level at diagnosis has been studied t
o determine if it is prognostic of outcome presumably because of its relati
on to tumour bulk or to the biological nature of the tumour. A more recent
trend has been to investigate tumour marker decline. The finding of a delay
ed rate of decline suggests a poorer response of the malignancy to chemothe
rapy. The major focus of the article will be on marker decline of AFP and H
CG as prognostic tools in peripheral and central nervous system (CNS) germ
cell tumours (GCTs) and hepatic tumours (hepatoblastoma and hepatocellular
carcinoma).
The articles reviewed here suggest that HCG and AFP can correlate with surv
ival if examined in specific ways, and could potentially be used to tailor
treatment for individual patients. One group of authors presents data on pa
tients with GCTs suggesting that satisfactory marker regression is an indep
endent prognostic factor for survival. In a study of hepatoblastoma, data d
emonstrate that both the magnitude and rate of decline are associated with
survival. Marker decline studies in hepatocellular carcinoma do not exist a
nd marker levels at diagnosis do not appear to have a role in potential the
rapeutic changes. However, data on fucosylated subtype of AFP, Lens culinar
is agglutinin A reactive AFP, has shown prognostic significance in hepatoce
llular carcinoma. The data for CNS GCTs are limited and studies examining s
erial cerebrospinal fluid HCG/AFP are ongoing.
In some diseases, issues relating to timing of marker sampling when examini
ng marker decline need to be studied in greater detail. Hopefully, marker d
ecline studies can be duplicated in the other diseases, to document a poten
tial role in determining outcome. Further studies are needed to test the ab
ility to alter therapy in attempts to improve survival while decreasing tox
icity to patients.