The objectives of this study were to compare liking and consumption measure
ments of the acceptability of butter, margarine, and two spreads made using
designer fats, and to describe the sensory attributes of the products. Thi
s study was conducted as part of a nutrition intervention study which inclu
ded a 1-month baseline data collection period and three 4-week intervention
s. Subjects for the liking and consumption portions of the study were 33 he
althy post-menopausal women. In addition, subjects for a corresponding desc
riptive analysis panel were students from the University of Minnesota. Prod
ucts tested by both groups of subjects were: butter and margarines, a dairy
spread made with cholesterol-reduced milk fat (CRAMF) and a spread made wi
th cholesterol-reduced lard mixed with vegetable oils (Appetize(R) Lard). L
iking and consumption were measured at normal meal times in the subjects' n
atural eating environment. Butter was most liked and margarine the least li
ked spread. Butter eaters (compared to margarine eaters) accounted for the
liking differences among samples; margarine eaters liked all products equal
ly. Butter eaters ate more spreads. Liking ratings were generally unrelated
to intake for the entire group of subjects and for individual subjects. De
scriptive analysis showed the flavor of the two spreads made from designer
fats to be more similar to margarine than to butter. The texture of CRAMF w
as more similar to butter; the texture of the Appetize(R) Lard was more sim
ilar to margarine. Thus the two designer fat spreads were as well accepted
by the subjects as their regularly used margarine. (C) 1999 Elsevier Scienc
e Ltd. All rights reserved.