Farmer-managed trials in south-east Nigeria to evaluate the rice variety Cisadane and estimate yield losses caused by the African rice gall midge, Orseolia oryzivora Harris & Gagne
Ct. Williams et al., Farmer-managed trials in south-east Nigeria to evaluate the rice variety Cisadane and estimate yield losses caused by the African rice gall midge, Orseolia oryzivora Harris & Gagne, INT J PEST, 45(2), 1999, pp. 117-124
Farmer-managed trials of the rice variety Cisadane were undertaken at 47 ra
infed lowland sites around Abakaliki, south-east Nigeria, a major outbreak
area of the African rice gall midge (ARGM). At each site a plot of Cisadane
was grown alongside a control plot of the participating farmer's usual var
iety. On average the Cisadane yielded 26% higher than the controls but ARGM
infestation levels on it were only slightly lower, suggesting that it had
greater tolerance to the pest but little antixenotic or antibiotic resistan
ce. For all of 14 evaluation criteria, most participating farmers rated Cis
adane as better than their control varieties. It appears to be a useful com
ponent for an ARGM management strategy. Regression analyses of yield on alt
ernative variables for ARGM infestation derived from data recorded at 3, 7
or II w.a.t. (weeks after transplanting) showed that the log-transformed pe
rcent tiller infestation at 7 w.a.t. was the best predictor of yield. Varia
bles for site topography, water level, fertilizer use in the nursery, and p
lant spacing also had significant partial regression coefficients. Excludin
g plots with tiller infestation levels above 30%, the relationship between
yield and infestation was approximately linear and suggested a yield loss o
f 2.9% per 1% increase in infestation.