Dr. Grimm et al., Airway hyperresponsiveness to ultrasonically nebulized distilled water in subjects with tetraplegia, J APP PHYSL, 86(4), 1999, pp. 1165-1169
The majority of otherwise healthy subjects with chronic cervical spinal cor
d injury (SCI) demonstrate airway hyperresponsiveness to aerosolized methac
holine or histamine. The present study was performed to determine whether u
ltrasonically nebulized distilled water (UNDW) induces airway hyperresponsi
veness and to further elucidate potential mechanisms in this population. Fi
fteen subjects with SCI, nine with tetraplegia (C4-7) and six with parapleg
ia (T-9-L-1), were initially exposed to UNDW for 30 s; spirometry was perfo
rmed immediately and again 2 min after exposure. The challenge continued by
progressively increasing exposure time until the forced expiratory volume
in 1 s decreased 20% or more from baseline (PD20) or the maximal exposure t
ime was reached. Five subjects responding to UNDW returned for a second cha
llenge 30 min after inhalation of aerosolized ipratropium bromide (2.5 mi o
f a 0.6% solution). Eight of nine subjects with tetraplegia had significant
bronchoconstrictor responses to UNDW (geometric mean PD20 = 7.76 +/- 7.67
mi), whereas none with paraplegia demonstrated a response (geometric mean P
D20 = 24 mi). Five of the subjects with tetraplegia who initially responded
to distilled water (geometric mean PD20 = 5.99 +/- 4.47 mi) were not respo
nsive after pretreatment with ipratropium bromide (geometric mean PD20 = 24
mi). Findings that subjects with tetraplegia are hyperreactive to UNDW, a
physicochemical agent, combined with previous observations of hyperreactivi
ty to methacholine and histamine, suggest that overall airway hyperresponsi
veness in these individuals is a nonspecific phenomenon similar to that obs
erved in patients with asthma. The ability of ipratropium bromide to comple
tely block UNDW-induced bronchoconstriction suggests that, in part, airway
hyperresponsiveness in subjects with tetraplegia represents unopposed paras
ympathetic activity.