The crack-modelling technique is a method for prediction of fatigue in comp
onents using finite element (FE) analysis. The technique, which is based on
the estimation of equivalent K factors fur stress-concentrators has had so
me initial success in analysing components of complex shape, but this has r
aised a number of questions about the potential accuracy of the method and
its sensitivity to the choice of operating parameters. The present paper re
ports on a systematic study using four different specimen types and one com
ponent geometry Accurate estimates of equivalent K values are shown to be p
ossible for both sharp notches and blunt notches, loaded in uniaxial tensio
n or bending, using a very simple approach in which the stress distribution
from the notch is compared to that from a standard cracked body. The metho
d shows some sensitivity to the optimization routines used, and to some ext
ent to the choice of the standard cracked body. It is relatively insensitiv
e to mesh refinement and can be used with simple, elastic FE models.