M. Addy et al., An evaluation of video instruction for an electric toothbrush - Comparative single-brushing cross-over study, J CLIN PER, 26(5), 1999, pp. 289-293
Instructions on the use of electric toothbrushes are usually derived from t
he written and/or diagrammatic leaflets provided with the device or perhaps
less often instruction from a professional. Videos are now widely used for
information transfer and the direction of physical activities. The aim of
this study was to determine whether video instruction in the use of an elec
tric toothbrush could promote efficient use of the device. The 2-min video
demonstrated the use of an oscillating, rotating electric toothbrush used b
y a hygienist for 15 s in each buccal and lingual quadrant. A voice-over di
rected the observer to follow the hygienist's movements. The study was plan
ned as a 2-phase, single-examiner blind, randomised, cross-over study accep
ting there would be confounding of the 2nd period by carry-over from the 1s
t. A group of 24 healthy volunteers participated who had average oral hygie
ne and never used an electric toothbrush. 12 subjects received the video fi
rst (VN) and 12 subjects the instructional leaflet with the device (NV). Si
ngle brushings were performed after suspending tooth cleaning for 48 h. Pla
que was scored before and after brushing. A 2-week washout period was permi
tted before the crossover. In period 1, plaque removal with the video was o
verall significantly greater than with written instructions. The effects fo
r posterior teeth were greater than anterior and comparison between groups
for posterior minus anterior differences were highly significant in favour
of the VN group. In period 2, the effect of period was dominant with both g
roups achieving greater plaque removal in period 2 than period 1. Plaque re
moval by group VN remained considerably greater than group NV. Despite the
confounding influences of carry-over in this particular design of study, th
e results support the idea that video instruction for electric toothbrushes
could be a simple and efficient way of improving plaque removal by these d
evices. The methodology needs to be verified in a home-use type of investig
ation.