This paper makes the point that an import-competing industry may not want m
aximal protection. The reason is that a high level of protection encourages
inward foreign direct investment, which could be even less desirable than
import competition. A government captured by the domestic import-competing
industry consequently will set the level of protection low enough to limit
direct foreign entry. This paper also establishes results regarding the for
m of protection. Voluntary export restraints are shown to be the domestic i
ndustry's desired means of protection, because leaving export rents with fo
reigners inhibits foreign direct investment.