The advantages and disadvantages of fracture characterization by using
either the stress intensity factor (K) or the strain energy release r
ate (J) were considered for paper and paperboard. Using the engineerin
g criterion for predicting strength of paper products, K is more usefu
l, because geometry factors for complicated geometries can be obtained
easily. Numerous test data demonstrate predictability. Tenacity, a si
mple test based on K, is presented. It is easy to interpret and more p
recise than J.