Pc. Chou et al., OPTIMIZATION OF J(C) OF YBCO THIN-FILMS PREPARED BY PHOTO-ASSISTED MOCVD THROUGH STATISTICAL ROBUST DESIGN, Physica. C, Superconductivity, 254(1-2), 1995, pp. 93-112
Intrinsically, the thin-film preparation technique of metalorganic che
mical vapor deposition involves a large number of control variables wh
ich are especially critical in work with quaternary or higher high-T-c
materials. Thus, effective methods are needed to optimize variable se
ttings in the preparation of high-T-c films. A matrix experimental pla
n and robust design methodology has been employed for this purpose. Th
e first design phase was based on existing knowledge regarding growth
temperature, pressure and annealing temperature for photo-assisted pre
paration of YBCO thin films on LaAlO3 (100) substrates. A battery of o
nly nine experiments plus three confirmation depositions were then use
d to optimize the process control parameters of precursor oven tempera
ture, carrier gas (Ar) flow rate, and the flow rates of two oxidizing
gases, O-2 and N2O, with respect to critical current density (J(c)) of
the films. J(c) (77 K, zero field) values for deposited YBCO films (w
ith thickness in the 0.4-0.6 mu m range) were found to be improved fro
m about 1 to 3 X 10(6) A/cm(2). J(c) for a thinner sample (0.15 mu m)
reached 5.0 X 10(6) A/cm(2). It was found that under these processing
conditions the most significant process control parameter affecting J(
c) is the flow rate of O-2, or more precisely, the oxidizing agent now
-rate ratio of O-2 and N2O. Analysis of the variance of the J(c) data
indicated that there likely exist interactions among some of the contr
ol variables, most obviously between the flow rates of O-2 and N2O.