In this paper we present a comprehensive noise and stability analysis of bo
th the current feedback and the voltage feedback op-amp when connected as t
ransimpedance amplifiers with capacitive current sources. It is generally a
ssumed that the current feedback op-amp is noisier than the voltage feedbac
k op-amp; we show how external component values play an important role in d
etermining the total equivalent input noise current spectral density and sh
ow that the voltage feedback op-amp may, in certain cases, be noisier than
the current feedback op-amp. Both amplifier types are compared in terms of
stability, noise and bandwidth; we find that the current feedback op-amp is
particularly suited for operation as a transimpedance amplifier. Theoretic
al analysis is confirmed by simulations of equivalent circuits of the curre
nt feedback op-amp and the voltage feedback op-amp, and simulations of the
macro models of two high performance commercially available op-amps, namely
the Elantec EL2260 current feedback op-amp and the Elantec EL2244 voltage
feedback op-amp.