Ecologists have fiercely debated for many decades whether populations
are self-regulated by density-dependent biological mechanisms or are c
ontrolled by exogenous environmental forces. Here, a stochastic mechan
istic model is used to show that the interaction of these two forces c
an explain observed large fluctuations in Dungeness crab (Cancer magis
ter) numbers. Relatively small environmental perturbations interact wi
th realistic nonlinear (density dependent) biological mechanisms, to p
roduce dynamics that are similar to observations. This finding has imp
lications throughout population biology, suggesting both that the stud
y of deterministic density-dependent models is highly problematic and
that stochastic models must include biologically relevant nonlinear me
chanisms.