Dw. Graham et al., Development of small outdoor microcosms for studying contaminant transformation rates and mechanisms under various water column conditions, ENV TOX CH, 18(6), 1999, pp. 1124-1132
Three outdoor microcosm treatments were developed to simulate aerobic (aero
bic), thermally stratified (stratified), and anaerobic (anaerobic) water co
lumns for assessing contaminant transformation rates under controlled, quas
i-natural conditions. Twelve 3.2-m-diameter by l.4-m-deep fiberglass tanks
(11.3 m(3) water volume) were used in the study, four for each treatment. T
he tanks were variably manipulated both physically (with internal frames an
d plastic layers) and chemically (with sediment trays and grass supplements
) to facilitate the three environments. The manipulations successfully crea
ted three different and reproducible (both between tanks with common treatm
ents and over time) aquatic systems for further study. The aerobic treatmen
t produced a good simulation of a P-limited, mesotrophic water column. Alte
rnately, both the stratified and anaerobic treatments developed eutrophic t
o hypereutrophic water conditions and had nutritionally balanced total nitr
ogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) levels (approximately 14:1 mg N/mg P).
Mild thermal stratification was achieved in the stratified units and low-ox
ygen conditions were established in the anaerobic units. A trial study, usi
ng the herbicide alachlor [2-chloro-2',6'-diethyl-N-(methoxymethyl)acetanil
ide], was performed to test the utility of the three microcosm designs for
assessing comparative in situ contaminant transformation rates. This experi
ment was initiated by adding alachlor to all tanks to a final concentration
of 50 mu g/L. Alachlor levels and other chemical parameters were then moni
tored for 36 d. The estimated first-order alachlor decay coefficients and h
alf-lives for the aerobic, stratified, and anaerobic treatments were 0.011/
d (63 d), 0.024/d (29 d), and 0.020/d (35 d), respectively. Subsequent anal
yses showed that the highest rates of alachlor decay occurred in units with
grass supplements, low DO and pH levels, and comparatively high TP levels.
These results suggest that lower nutrient (i.e., low TP levels), photosynt
hesis-dominated aquatic systems produce lower alachlor decay rates, whereas
higher nutrient, decomposition-dominated systems produce higher decay rate
s. This project shows that diverse physical and chemical environments can b
e created in small outdoor microcosms and that these systems can be used su
ccessfully to assess contaminant decay rates in natural systems.