The politics of distinction and disobedience: Honor and the defense of liberty in Montesquieu

Authors
Citation
S. Krause, The politics of distinction and disobedience: Honor and the defense of liberty in Montesquieu, POLITY, 31(3), 1999, pp. 469-499
Citations number
60
Categorie Soggetti
Politucal Science & public Administration
Journal title
POLITY
ISSN journal
00323497 → ACNP
Volume
31
Issue
3
Year of publication
1999
Pages
469 - 499
Database
ISI
SICI code
0032-3497(199921)31:3<469:TPODAD>2.0.ZU;2-D
Abstract
Elaborating Montesquieu's concept of honor illuminates a dimension of his l iberalism that has been neglected by prior commentary, and calls attention to a form of political motivation that has been overlooked in contemporary political theory. While honor avoids the anti-liberal tendencies of civic v irtue, it can motivate, better than self-interest does, the extraordinary a cts of courage and sacrifice sometimes needed to sustain individual liberti es. Following a brief account of how it fits into Montesquieu's typology of regimes, three features of honor are elaborated: its high ambitions; its m ix of reverence and reflexivity; and its partiality. The final section addr esses the relationship between honor and liberal democracy, arguing that de spite the tensions between them, liberal democracy needs honor in some form if it is to sustain itself over time.