Over the past decade risk society theory has become increasingly prominent
within the field of environmental social theory. This perspective contends
that conventional political divisions based on class are becoming less sali
ent and are giving way to a politics predicated upon the distribution of ri
sk. There is much in risk society theory, especially its central contention
that public anxieties about high consequence-low probability events underm
ine the :legitimacy of science, that has a distinctly German stamp. Through
a comparative analysis of how national context has differently shaped scie
nce as a public epistemology this paper suggests we should tread carefully
in moving to accept the general applicability of this theoretical approach.