K. Anastos et al., Prevalence of and risk factors for tuberculin positivity and skin test anergy in HIV-1-infected and uninfected at-risk women, J ACQ IMM D, 21(2), 1999, pp. 141-147
Objectives: To determine differences in rates of reactivity to purified pro
tein derivative (PPD) tuberculin and of skin test anergy in relationship to
serostatus, immune status, demographic characteristics, and other risk fac
tors in women infected with or at high risk for infection with HIV-1; and t
o compare the usefulness of three different antigens in assessing delayed t
ype hypersensitivity.
Design/Methods: Cross-sectional analysis of baseline data in a multicenter
prospective cohort study of 1343 HIV-l-seropositive and 390 seronegative bu
t at-risk women recruited from sites of HIV primary care and through commun
ity-based outreach for a longitudinal cohort study.
Results: 4.7% of the 1343 HIV-l-seropositive women and 15.4% of the 390 HIV
-seronegative women were tuberculin-positive (p < .001). A lower threshold
in millimeters of induration for tuberculin reactivity among HIV-seropositi
ve women resulted in a smaller difference between the seropositive and the
seronegative groups. Even when a 2-mm threshold was used in HIV-seropositiv
e respondents, with a IO-mm threshold among seronegative participants, the
difference between the seropositive (6.9% reactive) and the seronegative (1
5.4% reactive) groups remained statistically significant (p < .001). Limiti
ng analysis to women who responded to the non-PPD antigens did not eliminat
e the differences in PPD reactivity between the HIV-seropositive and HIV-se
ronegative women. In multivariate analysis, tuberculin reactivity was assoc
iated with HIV-negative serostatus, a history of tuberculosis infection or
disease, geographic site, and CD4 count >200 cells/mm(3) in the HIV-seropos
itive women. In all, 41% of HIV-seropositive, women and 12% of seronegative
women were anergic (p < .001). Candida antigen had the lowest response rat
es. In multivariate analyses, only HIV-serostatus and CD4 cell counts in HI
V-seropositive women were significantly associated with anergy.
Conclusions: In this community-based cohort of HIV-seropositive and HIV-ser
onegative women, we found significant differences between the seronegative
and seropositive women even with a lower threshold of induration defining P
PD reactivity among seropositive women and among women not anergic to the n
on-PPD antigens. Prevalence of PPD reactivity was higher than in previously
described in cohorts of homosexual men, but lower than in cohorts of predo
minantly male injection drug users. Rates of anergy were similar to those i
n most previously described cohorts.