Ba. Roy et Ml. Stanton, Asymmetry in wild mustard, Sinapis arvensis (Brassicaceae), in response tosevere physiological stresses, J EVOL BIOL, 12(3), 1999, pp. 440-449
It has often been assumed that when a severe stress is applied to a growing
Organism asymmetry in a number of different traits will occur due to abnor
mal development. To test whether asymmetry is correlated with fitness in pl
ants, and whether different environmental stresses cause distinct or simila
r forms of asymmetry, we measured fluctuating asymmetry in Sinapis arvensis
(Brassicaceae),grown in several environments: five characterized by a dist
inctive environmental stress (high boron,high salt, low water, low light, l
ow nutrients), and a 'control' environment that was as stress-free as possi
ble with ample water, nutrients and light. Relative to the controls, all of
the stress environments increased asymmetry and decreased fitness. Asymmet
ry fan be used to gauge environmental stress in S. arvensis, but the organ
affected depends on the stress. For example, petal asymmetry was greatest i
n the high salt treatment, whereas fruit asymmetry was greatest in the low
light treatment. Asymmetry also varied among traits within individuals; an
individual's asymmetry rank depended on which organ was being examined.. Fi
nally, individual fitness was not strongly correlated with asymmetry, indic
ating that asymmetry cannot be used to cull stress-intolerant individuals f
rom a population during selection. Our results suggest that asymmetry may o
ften be specific, and not general. Under a specific asymmetry model, a part
icular stress affects the development of a particular organ or set of organ
s, but not necessarily the whole plant.