A. Hakkinen et al., Dynamic strength training in patients with early rheumatoid arthritis increases muscle strength but not bone mineral density, J RHEUMATOL, 26(6), 1999, pp. 1257-1263
Objective. To assess the effects of 12 months' dynamic strength training on
muscle strength and bone mineral density (BMD) at the lumbar spine and fem
oral neck in patients with early rheumatoid arthritis (RA).
Methods. Thirty-two subjects in the training group (EG) and 33 in the contr
ol group (CG) completed the study. EG carried out strength training 2 times
a week with moderate loads of 50-70% of repetition maximum. They were also
encouraged to do recreational physical activities. CG performed recreation
al physical activities and range of motion exercises. Maximal strength of t
he knee extensors, trunk extensors and flexors, and grip strength were reco
rded with dynamometers. BMD was measured using dual x-ray absorptiometry. M
odified Disease Activity Score, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, and pain we
re used for the estimation of disease activity, and Stanford Health Assessm
ent Questionnaire to measure functional disability
Results, The 12 month resistance training in EG led to statistically signif
icant mean increases of 22-35% in all muscle groups examined. CG patients w
ere also able to increase their strength to some degree (3-24%), but at the
end of the study strengths in CG were significantly lower than in EG. By t
he end of the study lumbar spine BMD had changed by +0.19% (4.24) in EG and
by -1.14% (4.36) in CG, The corresponding changes of femoral BMD were +1.1
0% (3.71) and -0.03% (3.58). The changes in BMD were minor and statisticall
y not significant in both groups. However, femoral BMD was found to be decr
eased among those patients treated periodically with oral glucocorticoids (
n = 15, 3 subjects from EG and 12 from CG) compared with changes in BMD amo
ng those not treated with systemic glucocorticoids (n = 50).
Conclusion, Minimally supervised strength training resulted in significant
improvements in muscle strength without detrimental effects on disease acti
vity. The detected annual changes in central BMD were minor and statistical
ly insignificant in both groups. Special attention should be focused on tho
se patients with RA with high disease activity and concomitant glucocortico
id treatment.