Jl. Koh et al., Efficacy of parental application of eutectic mixture of local anesthetics for intravenous insertion, PEDIATRICS, 103(6), 1999, pp. E791-E795
Objective. To demonstrate that parent application of eutectic mixture of lo
cal anesthetics (EMLA) results in equal reduction of the pain of intravenou
s (IV) placement compared with clinician application of EMLA, and to assess
potential difficulties with parental application.
Study Design. A 2 x 2 randomized block design was used, with 41 children di
vided into two age groups (5-12 years vs 13-18 years) and randomized to one
of two experimental groups (parent-applied EMLA vs clinician-applied EMLA)
.
Methods. All children were scheduled to have outpatient gastrointestinal en
doscopies with IV sedation. EMLA was placed at least 60 minutes before IV i
nsertion either by the parent or a clinician, depending on the experimental
group assignment. Outcome measures were child pain ratings and observed be
havioral distress ratings. Parents and children were interviewed to determi
ne parent and child anxiety levels in anticipation of the IV insertion, pre
vious needle stick experience, and previous difficulty coping. Feasibility
outcomes included technical difficulty with application of EMLA and appeara
nce of the EMLA cream and occlusive covering.
Results. Pain ratings and behavioral distress ratings were generally in the
low to moderate range for all groups and were consistent with previous emp
iric reports of EMLA outcome. There were no significant differences in pain
or distress ratings for either the age or the experimental groups. Parent
ratings of their child's previous difficulty coping was related to the leve
l of behavioral distress exhibited before (r = .50), during (r = .32) and a
fter (r = .44) the IV insertion. In addition, children's anxiety ratings ab
out IV insertion seemed to differ among groups (although not statistically
significant for post hoc comparisons), with the most anxiety reported by th
e younger children when clinicians applied the EMLA and by older children w
hen parents applied the EMLA.
Conclusion. Parent application of EMLA appears to be as effective as clinic
ian application in reducing children's pain and distress associated with IV
insertion. Permitting parents to apply the EMLA at home can allow children
who are having procedures on an outpatient basis to benefit from topical a
nesthesia without having to arrive early to the clinic or hospital. Additio
nally, application by parents may result in less anticipatory anxiety for y
ounger children.