Continuum concepts are used to evaluate the competition between crack advan
ce and dislocation nucleation at the tip of a crack having a finite tip cur
vature. The analysis reveals that the favorability of crack propagation ver
sus dislocation emission depends upon the bluntness of the crack tip. One i
mplication is that a crack may initially emit dislocations only to reinitia
te cleavage upon reaching a sufficiently blunted tip geometry. The present
framework is used to classify crystals as intrinsically ductile or brittle
in terms of the unstable stacking energy, the surface energy, and the peak
cohesive stresses achieved during opening and shear of the atomic planes. [
S0031-9007(99)09235-2].