L. Gandini et al., STUDY OF ANTISPERM ANTIBODIES BOUND TO THE SPERM CELL-SURFACE AND THEIR RELATIONSHIP TO CIRCULATING ASA, American journal of reproductive immunology [1989], 34(6), 1995, pp. 375-380
PROBLEM: Direct and indirect tests for antisperm antibody (ASA) detect
ion are commonly used in laboratories for the diagnosis of male immuno
logical infertility. Even though the two kinds of tests study the same
immunological phenomena, frequently no perfect correlation is found e
ven on large series of patients and with precise statistical models. T
he aim of the present investigation was to try to establish whether bi
ological models can explain the antibody test results and if a predict
ive threshold can be established for expected positivity/negativity. M
ETHOD: The data relate to 667 patients, who were screened using the Di
rect Immunobead test (d-IBT) for ASA bound to the sperm surface and wi
th the gelatin and tray agglutination test (GAT and TAT) in sera for c
irculating ASA, Correlations were studied and cases of no correlation
were further analyzed. RESULTS: The number of patients with a clinical
ly significant positivity to d-LBT (binding percentage greater than or
equal to 20%) was 134 (20.1 % of total patients). The analysis of the
results of direct and indirect tests shows that the discordances are
due to differences in the Ig class of immunization or to the site of e
pitopes involved. In fact, as far the Ig class is concerned, if d-IBT
shows a prevalent or exclusive IgG or IgA positivity, this results in
a poor correlation between binding percentage to d-IBT and GAT-TAT tit
ers. If both the Ig classes are involved, the level of positivity of t
he two kinds of test are strictly related. As far as the site of Ag-Ab
reaction on the sperm surface is concerned, the wide immunization inv
olving all the surface sperm antigens (mixed), shown by d-IBT, is rela
ted to higher indirect test titers. CONCLUSION: Local and systemic ant
isperm immunizations are strictly related and a predictive threshold o
f expectation can be established to explain even apparently discordant
direct and indirect results.