Deconstruction's promise: Derrida's rethinking of Marxism

Authors
Citation
E. Macdonald, Deconstruction's promise: Derrida's rethinking of Marxism, SCI SOC, 63(2), 1999, pp. 145-172
Citations number
15
Categorie Soggetti
Sociology & Antropology
Journal title
SCIENCE & SOCIETY
ISSN journal
00368237 → ACNP
Volume
63
Issue
2
Year of publication
1999
Pages
145 - 172
Database
ISI
SICI code
0036-8237(199922)63:2<145:DPDROM>2.0.ZU;2-O
Abstract
Derrida's treatise on Marxism, Spectres of Marx; sheds light on the politic s of Derridean deconstruction. It is worth taking seriously Derrida's effor ts to ally his project, both strategically and critically, with a "left," " democratic," even Marxist one, and to advance the debate regarding the stat us of deconstruction within such a project. Nevertheless, his reading of Ma rxism and his call for a New International indicate the limitations of deco nstructive theory for precisely the kind of strategic and radically democra tic project that Derrida advocates, These limitations arise from a number o f sources, including: an abiding ambivalence regarding the "materialist" st atus of his project, the difficulties that arise from his definition of "ju stice" as differance in application to an analysis of oppression, an oversi mplification of debates about the ontological status of class in Marxist th eory, confusion regarding the political logic of the radical democratic pro ject, and both inconsistency and vagueness in the theorization of the "pres ent" proposed in deconstructive terms.