E. Masciadri et al., 3D mapping of optical turbulence using an atmospheric numerical model II.First results at Cerro Paranal, ASTR AST SS, 137(1), 1999, pp. 203-216
The first statistical results of simulations of optical turbulence over Cer
ro Paranal by an atmospheric non-hydrostatic model (Meso-Nh) are presented.
Measurements from the whole PARSCA93 campaign are analyzed. Simulations ar
e compared to optical measurements obtained by a Scidar and a DIMM working
at the same time during 14 nights 13-26 May 1993 over Paranal (Chile). An o
rographic model with a horizontal resolution of 500 m is implemented in Mes
o-Nh to study its sensitivity to the orographic effects. The model is initi
alized with radiosoundings profiles provided by Antofagasta station (70.43
W, 23.43 S) and ECMWF analyses extracted from the nearest grid point (70.31
W, 23.62 S) to this meteorological station. A detailed quality study of ra
diosounding and analyses is presented. No radiosoundings were provided by A
ntofagasta station during 4 nights and numerical instabilies were generated
by the model during the 13 and 26 May 1993 nights. So, only 8 nights were
actually studied. Two statistical methods are presented: Method A has a hig
h temporal resolution, Method B has a high vertical spatial resolution. Met
hod A compares integrated values (seeing) provided by simulations and measu
rements, Method B compares the C-N(2) profiles. Different statistical estim
ators are computed for both the methods. We demonstrate that the model can
reproduce well the spatial distribution of the optical turbulence in both t
he high and low atmospheric regions but the unreliability of Antofagasta ra
diosoundings hampers the statistical results of the numerical technique. To
better test the performance of the model, a comparison between the numeric
al and the forecasting-by-persistence techniques is presented. With a poor
statistical sample (only 8 nights), no conclusive statements can be made ab
out the performances of the two techniques. The model ability to discrimina
te between the best (epsilon = 0.38) and the worst (epsilon = 1.38) nights
of the campaign is promising for the future implementation of the numerical
technique for flexible scheduling of telescopes.