Da. Nardi, Ethical and methodological issues in evaluating a perinatal addiction treatment program with a fluid population, QUAL HEAL R, 9(4), 1999, pp. 559-567
A naturalistic field study was used to evaluate a fluid sample population i
n an addiction treatment program. This article presents the methodological
and ethical issues in program evaluation confronted by the author and the a
pproaches developed to address them. Methodological issues include credibil
ity and fittingness of instrumental, lack of standardization of histories,
replication, trust issues of subjects, attrition, client follow-up, and rap
idly changing subject population. Ethical issues include informed consent,
interpretation of data from a cultural bias-free perspective and client fol
low-up. A semistructured interview schedule allowed for standardization of
the questioning format and replication of data gathering. Triangulation of
data enhanced validity and internal stability. A fluid sample frame can opt
imally reflect the population in the program under study if available resou
rces are used! effectively while protecting patient rights to privacy, conf
identiality, and freedom from manipulation.