Mr. Serper et al., Symptomatic overlap of cocaine intoxication and acute schizophrenia at emergency presentation, SCHIZO BULL, 25(2), 1999, pp. 387-394
Cocaine intoxication and acute abstinence alter brain dopaminergic function
ing, resulting in behavioral changes closely mimicking the positive and neg
ative symptoms of schizophrenia. In emergency room settings, recent cocaine
abuse can be mistaken for schizophrenia and may cause inappropriate diagno
sis and in some instances medical mismanagement. Schizophrenia patients pre
senting with recent cocaine abuse may also present with significant diagnos
tic and treatment dilemmas. This study attempts to distinguish between coca
ine and schizophrenic psychosis by examining patients who present with both
recent cocaine abuse and acute schizophrenia (CA+SZ), cocaine intoxication
without schizophrenic illness (CA), and acute schizophrenia with no comorb
id substance abuse (SZ) within the first 24 hours after arrival at the Bell
evue psychiatric emergency service. Clinical assessment included the Brief
Psychiatric Rating Scale, the Schedule for the Assessment of Positive Sympt
oms, and the Schedule for the Assessment of Negative Symptoms. Both cocaine
abusing groups were required to have positive urine toxicology screens for
inclusion in the study. Multivariate analysis of variance showed the CA+SZ
patients present with a clinical profile that overlaps with CA patients on
mood and negative symptom dimensions and overlaps with SZ patients on most
positive symptoms. CA+SZ patients differed from both groups, however, by p
resenting with significantly more hallucinatory experiences than cocaine ab
using or schizophrenia patient counterparts. Despite considerable overlap,
each group of patients presented with a discernible cross-sectional symptom
pattern.