This paper experimentally shows that mixed-initiative dialogue is not alway
s more efficient than non-mixed initiative dialogue in route finding tasks.
Based on the dialogue model proposed in Conversation Analysis and Discours
e Analysis a la the Birmingham school and Whittaker and Stenton's definitio
n of initiative, we implement dialogue systems and obtain experimental resu
lts by making the systems interact with each other. Across a variety of ins
tantiations of the dialogue model, the results show that with easy problems
, the efficiency of mixed-initiative dialogue is a little better than or eq
ual to that of non-mixed-initiative dialogue, while with difficult problems
mixed-initiative dialogue is less efficient than non-mixed-initiative dial
ogue.