G. Antonucci et al., VISUAL FACTORS AFFECTING THE ROD-AND-FRAME ILLUSION - ROLE OF GAP SIZE AND FRAME COMPONENTS, Perception, 24(10), 1995, pp. 1119-1130
In two studies the effect of the distance between the tip of the rod a
nd the frame sides (gap) in the rod-and-frame (RF) illusion was examin
ed and the effect of a full-square condition was compared with that of
two different frame amputations. In both studies, there were more rod
-setting errors in the direction of the tilt of the inducing figure wi
th a small gap than with a large one. These findings are consistent wi
th the idea that in the case of small gap size local interactions cont
ribute to determining the RF illusion. The actual length of the rod wa
s varied in order to keep the gap constant across different frame tilt
s; therefore these findings cannot be due to the co-variation between
gap size and frame tilt which is typical of standard apparatuses. The
effect of frame amputations was compared to the full-square condition.
According to Wenderoth and Beh, amputations that maintain the two ort
hogonal contours of the square produce the typical angular function of
the RF illusion. This prediction was confirmed in both studies. Howev
er, results indicate that the full square has a stronger illusory effe
ct in the case of a small degree of tilt of the inducing stimulus, irr
espective of gap size. It is suggested that this 'square superiority'
effect is related to global, not local, mechanisms. To pursue Wenderot
h and Beh's observations, amputations close to the vertical meridian w
ere used in one experiment and those close to the horizontal meridian
in the second experiment. Contrary to predictions, these conditions pr
oduced overlapping results.