If it takes longer to achieve a single phonological representation for inco
nsistent words (e.g., BOWL) than for consistent words (e.g., BENT), and if
phonological coherence is pivotal to visual word recognition, then identity
priming should depend on consistency. This hypothesis was evaluated in nam
ing and lexical decision within a 4-field presentation sequence of mask-pri
me-mask-target. The prime-target stimulus onset asynchrony (SOA) was either
114 or 244 ms (with prime durations, respectively, of 43 and 129 ms). Four
experiments compared identity primes such as BOWL and BENT, which were equ
ated, on average, for total number of friendly and unfriendly neighbors, bi
gram frequency, and number of 1-letter-different neighbors. In both tasks,
BENT primed itself better than BOWL primed itself with the difference being
larger at the shorter SOA. Word processing is constrained primarily by the
rate of achieving a coherent phonological code.