Eugenics is generally regarded as evil; but what was its sin? Racism, class
bias, and violation of reproductive freedom, which tainted objectionable e
ugenic interventions, are not part of the core notion of eugenics. A number
of candidates have been suggested as the wrong inherent in eugenics, rangi
ng from statism to the impossibility of consensus on the ideal human being.
It is most plausible to view eugenics as sharing moral dilemmas with much
of public health, and the critical issues as those of distributive justice.