Np. Hanan et al., ERRORS IN REMOTE-SENSING OF INTERCEPTED PHOTOSYNTHETICALLY ACTIVE RADIATION - AN EXAMPLE FROM HAPEX-SAHEL, Journal of hydrology, 189(1-4), 1997, pp. 676-696
Canopy PAR interception (IPAR) is an important variable in many models
of canopy photosynthesis and net primary production. IPAR can be esti
mated remotely using spectral vegetation indices (VI). However, IPAR e
stimates by this method are subject to errors (E) associated with (i)
the estimation of fractional interception (f(PAR)) from a VI measureme
nt (E-F), (ii) the accuracy of estimates of incident PAR (E-T) and (ii
i) the interaction of these errors (E-X). During the HAPEX-Sahel exper
iment in Niger in 1991 the temporal evolution of a VI was measured ove
r the study sites with a radiometer mounted in a light aircraft. Groun
d measurements of f(PAR) and incident PAB on HAPEX West Central shrub
fallow, grass fallow, degraded shrub fallow and millet sites were avai
lable. The f(PAR) measurements were used to determine the relationship
between the VI and fractional interception. The aircraft measurements
were then used. together with remote estimates of incident PAR from t
he TOMS satellite. to estimate IPAR through the season and to quantify
the error sources. Both E-F and E-T can result in large absolute and
relative errors in IPAR estimates, E-X was generally small. In ten-day
summations on the shrub and grass fallow sites, the total errors were
mostly less than 20% of the round measurements. On the millet and deg
raded shrub fallow, the ten-day errors were more substantial. The erro
rs at short time steps (1-10 days) cancel when summed for the whole gr
owing season. In applications where the precise daily errors in IPAR e
stimates cannot be quantified, the statistical uncertainty of the esti
mates can be evaluated if the uncertainty in the input variables is kn
own. The standard error of IPAR estimates is then dependent on the res
idual variance in the regression between vegetation index and f(PAR) a
nd on the mean square error of the remote estimates of incident PAR.