Male bushcrickets transfer a spermatophore at mating that consists of a spe
rm-containing ampulla and a product of the accessory glands, the spermatoph
ylax, that is consumed by the female during insemination. Male Requena vati
calis produce functionally different spermatophores depending on the availa
bility of sexually receptive females. They will maintain high mating freque
ncy by providing a gift sufficient to ensure sperm transfer, or will invest
parentally in females when their mating frequency is low. We examined the
relationship between male quality and nuptial feeding under conditions wher
e males invest in ejaculate protection or in parental investment. When inve
sting in ejaculate protection, males reduced the quality of the spermatophy
lax meal by I educing both the concentration of protein and the absolute am
ount of protein it contained. There was no relationship between male phenot
ype and gift size or quality. Moreover, we could find no evidence for the r
ecently advanced hypothesis that females can exercise mate choice by interf
ering with insemination. However, when males were investing parentally, we
found a positive association between spermatophylax size and male size, but
no relationship between protein content and male size. Males with high lev
els of fluctuating asymmetry invested more heavily in the nutritional conte
nt of their spermatophylaxes than did symmetrical males. Thus, male quality
does influence nuptial feeding, but in a manner predicted by a model of in
direct fitness benefits from mate choice.