Previous neuropsychological studies have demonstrated an association betwee
n false recognition and frontal lobe dysfunction. In the experiments report
ed here we explore the contribution of memory impairment and executive dysf
unction to the pathogenesis of false facial recognition in patients with fo
cal frontal lobe damage. Memory illusions in response to novel faces were o
bserved in both anterograde and retrograde tests efface recognition memory.
However, in neither memory domain could false recognition be accounted for
by face memory loss. Instead, our findings suggest that false facial recog
nition in frontal patients reflects the breakdown of strategic memory retri
eval, monitoring, and decision functions critical for attributing the exper
ience of familiarity to a specific source. Frontal executive memory functio
ns are primarily recruited under conditions of uncertainty when the face cu
e does not automatically elicit relevant contextual information, leaving th
e source of familiarity unspecified. Our results indicate that frontal pati
ents do not spontaneously engage in effortful recollection of specific cont
exts that can normally be used to oppose and inhibit recognition decisions
based on general or context-free familiarity. However, frontal patients can
use context recollection to suppress false recognition once this strategy
is pointed out to them. In some frontal patients false recognition may be m
aterial-specific.