This study was conducted to measure the frequency of contact with emergency
departments in Italy because of migraine, and to compare the initial diagn
osis of headache with the diagnosis after application of the International
Headache Society (IHS) criteria.
A retrospective observational method was used, consisting of an analysis of
the records of patients admitted to nine Italian emergency departments dur
ing different 4-month periods in 1994. Comparison of the initial diagnosis
with the diagnosis after application of the IHS diagnostic criteria was per
formed.
More than 31 million emergency department contacts were reported in Italy d
uring 1994. In the same year, 543 630 patients visited the nine emergency d
epartments enrolled in the study, with 169 569 of these contacts occurring
in the 4-month period analyzed in the study. We excluded from the analysis
all cases of secondary headache fully recognized at the emergency departmen
t admission (ie, traumas, intracranial pathology systemic diseases). The to
tal number of patients included in our analysis was 1043 (0.6%). The 934 pa
tients who could be fully evaluated were initially classified as having mig
raine; cluster headache; headache not otherwise specified; or diagnosed in
the emergency department as suffering from headache, but reclassified by ot
her departments as suffering from a different disease. After retrospective
application of the IHS classification, the diagnostic distribution was modi
fied, revealing that 18% of patients with migraine and 5% with cluster head
aches had previously been classified as having headache not otherwise speci
fied; a further 6% of cases with migraine and 0.4% of patients with cluster
headache had previously been classified as having secondary headaches. The
diagnosis of headache not otherwise specified was made with notable freque
ncy, indicating the limits of emergency department logs and the difficulty
in carrying out a retrospective analysis and reassessment of diagnosis.
The majority (88%) of patients assessed had not taken drugs for headache in
the 48 hours before the emergency department contact, suggesting that in I
taly emergency departments are used instead of a visit to the general pract
itioner. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs were the most frequently pres
cribed drugs in the emergency departments for this group of diagnoses.
The research revealed, on the one hand, that headache is a numerically sign
ificant phenomenon in the emergency department setting and, on the other, t
he need to apply prospective designs to this kind of survey.