E. Smit et al., Estimates of animal and plant protein intake in US adults: Results from the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 1988-1991, J AM DIET A, 99(7), 1999, pp. 813-820
Objective To describe the sources of protein intake in a sample of the US a
dult population and among subgroups defined by race-ethnicity, age, and gen
der.
Design The Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 1988-199
1, is a stratified random sample of the total civilian noninstitutionalized
population, drawn from the 50 United States and the District of Columbia.
For all foods consumed by the participants, based on a 24-hour dietary reca
ll, protein sources and the contribution of each protein type to the total
protein intake were determined.
Subjects Adult participants in the third National Health and Nutrition Exam
ination Survey (n = 7,924).
Statistical analyses Weighted total, age-specific, and age-adjusted mean pr
otein intakes were calculated using SAS and WesVarPC. Statistical differenc
es were determined by 2-tailed t tests.
Results The main protein source in the American diet is animal protein (69%
). Meat, fish, and poultry protein combined contributed the most to animal
protein (42%), followed by dairy protein (20%). Grains (18%) contributed th
e most to plant protein consumption. Women consumed a lower percentage of b
eef (14%) and pork (7%) protein than did men (18% and 9%, respectively). Wo
men also consumed a higher percentage of poultry (13%), dairy (22%), and fr
uit and vegetable (11%) protein than did men (11%, 19%, and 9%, respectivel
y). Blacks reported eating a higher percentage of poultry (18%) and pork (1
1%) protein and a lower percent of dairy protein (14%) than did whites (12%
, 7%, and 22%, respectively) and Mexican-Americans (11%, 8%, and 17%, respe
ctively). Mexican-Americans consumed a higher percentage of legume (7%) and
egg (7%) protein than did whites (4% and 4%, respectively) and blacks (4%
and 5%, respectively). Whites consumed a higher percentage of grain protein
(19%) than did blacks (16%) and Mexican-Americans (15%).
Conclusions These results show that, although the percentage of total energ
y from protein may be similar among race-ethnicities and between men and wo
men, their sources of protein are different. These differences should be ta
ken into account when providing nutrition education for specific population
s.