This paper examines the J-curve hypothesis for US agricultural and manufact
ured goods, using the Shiller lag model. The results support the J-curve ef
fect for agricultural goods, but not for manufactured goods. These findings
explain why many studies in the literature fail to support the J-curve phe
nomenon. There are two explanations for these findings: (1) the aggregation
bias of data that combine both agricultural and manufactured goods and (2)
the country under study is often an industrial nation like the US or Japan
with a high proportion of manufactured goods in both exports and imports.