Experimental studies have shown that diffuse axonal injury is usually induc
ed by positive or negative acceleration mechanisms. In order to determine t
he reliability of axonal injury (AI) as a marker of this type of traumatic
insult, we compared cases of trauma-induced focal cortical hemorrhage witho
ut dural involvement (n = 67) with cases of trauma-induced subdural bleedin
g without cortical hemorrhage (n = 26). Both groups exhibited a wide range
of post-traumatic survival times. The injuries in the first group were caus
ed mainly by direct impact to the head, those in the second by acceleration
/deceleration mechanisms. The investigations were based primarily on immuno
histochemical demonstration of antibodies targeted to beta-amyloid precurso
r protein (beta-APP) in the pens as a marker of AI and the results were ass
essed semiquantitatively. No significant differences were found between the
two groups. In both groups AI was detected in 80-100% of cases with surviv
al times of more than 3 h and two thirds of all positive cases showed prono
unced positivity. Additional comparison of cases of brain death due to mech
anical trauma (n = 14) with cases of brain death due to non-mechanical trau
ma (n = Is) also disclosed no significant intergroup differences. Finally,
investigations of the pens in cases of non-traumatic death due to cerebral
hypoxia/ischemia (n = 51) demonstrated AI with the same frequency as in the
other groups, although the expression tended to be less pronounced. Our re
sults confirm that beta-APP expression in the pens is a reliable indicator
of AI but does not discriminate between injuries caused by traumatic strain
or shearing mechanisms and secondary damage due to cerebral hypoxia/ischem
ia or edema. In the large majority of cases with prolonged post-traumatic s
urvival, it can therefore be assumed that Al in the pens is the consequence
of primary and/or secondary events or a combination of both, as is common
in non-missile head injury survived for more than 90-120 min. Therefore, po
sitive differentiation of the type of biomechanical event based on this cri
terion alone is not possible.