Adherence to asthma practice guidelines is low. Improved compliance could p
otentially improve care of patients with asthma. The purpose of this study
was to determine if patients managed in a general practice with an associat
ed asthma clinic are more likely to use asthma medications according to cli
nical practice guidelines than patients managed in the general surgery of t
he practice. A cross-sectional study of adult asthmatics, aged 18-55 years,
was conducted in six British general practices. Prescription data an ail a
sthma medication was collected for a 6-month period. Information on asthma
clinic attendance, age, sex, employment status, other medical illness, and
how patients used their inhaled beta(2)-agonist was collected through quest
ionnaire. The prescription data for asthma medication and patient use of in
haled beta(2)-agonist were compared to the British Thoracic Society's (BTS)
Guidelines for Management of Asthma in Adults to determine if the patient'
s asthma medication regimen was appropriate. There was no significant assoc
iation found between appropriate asthma medication and asthma clinic attend
ance or other patient characteristics. Adherence to the BTS guidelines was
low. Fifty-eight percent of the asthma patients used asthma medication regi
mens that were not consistent with the BTS guidelines published 1 year earl
ier, Adherence to the BTS guidelines was low regardless of patient characte
ristics, including asthma clinic attendance, age, sex, employment status, o
ther medical illness, or individual practice. These findings underscore the
need to document the utility of clinical practice guidelines which may imp
rove physician compliance.