Zs. Hendsch et B. Tidor, Electrostatic interactions in the GCN4 leucine zipper: Substantial contributions arise from intramolecular interactions enhanced on binding, PROTEIN SCI, 8(7), 1999, pp. 1381-1392
The GCN4 leucine zipper is a peptide homodimer that has been the subject of
a number of experimental and theoretical investigations into the determina
nts of affinity and specificity. Here, we utilize this model system to inve
stigate electrostatic effects in protein binding using continuum calculatio
ns. A particularly novel feature of the computations made here is that they
provide an interaction-by-interaction breakdown of the electrostatic contr
ibutions to the free energy of docking that includes changes in the interac
tion of each functional group with solvent and changes in interactions betw
een all pairs of functional groups on binding. The results show that (1) el
ectrostatic effects disfavor binding by roughly 15 kcal/mol due to desolvat
ion effects that are incompletely compensated in the bound state, (2) while
no groups strongly stabilize binding, the groups that are most destabilizi
ng are charged and polar side chains at the interface that have been implic
ated in determining binding specificity, and (3) attractive intramolecular
interactions (e.g., backbone hydrogen bonds) that are enhanced on binding d
ue to reduced solvent screening in the bound state contribute significantly
to affinity and are likely to be a general effect in other complexes. A co
mparison is made between the results obtained in an electrostatic analysis
carried out calculationally and simulated results corresponding to idealize
d data from a scanning mutagenesis experiment. It is shown that scanning ex
periments provide incomplete information on interactions and, if overinterp
reted, tend to overestimate the energetic effect of individual side chains
that make attractive interactions. Finally, a comparison is made between th
e results available from a continuum electrostatic model and from a simpler
surface-area dependent solvation model. In this case, although the simpler
model neglects certain interactions, on average it performs rather well.