Cmt. Greenwood et al., Statistical issues in a metaregression analysis of randomized trials: Impact on the dietary sodium intake and blood pressure relationship, BIOMETRICS, 55(2), 1999, pp. 630-636
In a meta-analysis of randomized trials of the effects of dietary sodium in
terventions on blood pressure, we found substantial heterogeneity among the
studies. We were interested in evaluating whether measurement error, known
to be a problem for dietary sodium measures, publication bias, or confound
ing factors could be responsible for the heterogeneity. A measurement error
correction was developed that corrects both the slope and the intercept an
d takes into account the sample size of each study and the number of measur
ements taken on an individual. The measurement error correction had a minim
al effect on the estimates, although it performed well in simulated data. A
smoothed scatter plot was used to assess publication bias. Metaregressions
provide a convenient way to jointly assess the effects of several factors,
but care must be taken to fit an appropriate model.