The reaction pathway for the formation of methane from acetate was investig
ated in sludge from 13 different biogas reactors. By following the conversi
on of [2-C-14]acetate and [C-14]bicarbonate it was shown that methane forma
tion by syntrophic acetate oxidation was the dominating mechanism for aceto
trophic methanogenesis in sludge containing high levels of salts, mainly am
monium, and volatile fatty acids. In one biogas reactor the degree of syntr
ophic acetate oxidation increased as the concentrations of salts and volati
le fatty acids increased. Statistical evaluation with principal component a
nalysis showed a close correlation between the degree of syntrophic acetate
oxidation and the concentrations of ammonium and potassium. The acetate de
gradation rate was lower (10-800 times) in biogas reactors in which methane
was formed through syntrophic acetate oxidation than in biogas reactors wh
ere acetate was directly cleaved to methane and carbon dioxide. Microscopic
observations revealed a predominance of one type of methanogen in the reac
tors with syntrophic acetate oxidation. Isolation and characterization, inc
luding substrate spectrum, mol% G+C, polyamine and 16S rRNA analysis, showe
d that the strains were hydrogenotrophic methanogens belonging to the genus
Methanoculleus. (C) 1999 Federation of European Microbiological Societies.
Published by Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.