The theory of the geomorphological unit hydrograph (GUH) is examined critic
ally and it is shown chat the inherent assumption that the operation of the
drainage network may be modelled by a corresponding network of linear rese
rvoirs so restricts the instantaneous unit hydrograph (IUH) shape that the
effects of further restrictions, reflecting the constraints imposed by the
geomorphological laws of the channel network, cannot easily be identified.
Without such identification, the geomorphological unit hydrograph theory is
untestable and must remain only a plausible hypothesis providing an indica
tion of a two-parameter IUH whose shape and scale factors must still be rel
ated empirically to appropriate catchment characteristics.