Stress intensity factor (SIF) for the elliptical crack under polynomial (un
iform, as a special case) loading was first given by Kassir and Sih (1975).
However, their expressions contain an error, corrected by Fabrikant (1987)
. This correction appears to have gone largely unnoticed, and some authors
still use the incorrect result.
We demonstrate, on the limiting case of a very elongated crack, that the co
rrect expression is indeed the one of Fabrikant. This is hoped to resolve t
he controversy. It is also pointed out how to correct other results of Kass
ir and Sih for various loadings.